How to Break in a Softball Catchers Mitt?

Softball catchers face the challenge of breaking in new mitts to ensure optimal performance. A well-broken-in mitt makes catching easier and reduces the risk of injury. But how can one achieve this effectively and efficiently?

The key to breaking in a softball catcher’s mitt lies in a combination of techniques, including steaming, oiling, and playing catch. Employing these methods will soften the leather, enhance flexibility, and mold the mitt to the user’s hand.

Unlock the full potential of your catcher’s mitt by following our detailed guide. Discover the best practices and expert tips that will make your mitt game-ready in no time. Stay with us, and you’ll be catching like a pro soon enough.

Understanding Catcher’s Mitts

A catcher’s mitt is different from other baseball gloves. Designed specifically for the catcher’s position, these mitts have extra padding to protect the hand from fast pitches. 

They also have a unique shape, with a shallow pocket and a closed web to provide better control over the ball. Due to their design, catcher’s mitts require a bit more effort to break in properly.

The Importance of Breaking in a Mitt

Breaking in a mitt is essential for several reasons:

  • Comfort: A properly broken-in mitt conforms to your hand, providing a comfortable fit.
  • Flexibility: Breaking in a mitt makes it more flexible, allowing you to catch and control the ball more effectively.
  • Durability: A well-conditioned mitt is less prone to damage and will last longer.
how to break in a softball catchers mitt fast

Preparation: Gather the Right Tools

Before you begin breaking in your catcher’s mitt, make sure you have the following tools on hand:

  • A baseball or softball
  • A rubber mallet
  • A glove steamer (optional)
  • Glove oil or conditioner
  • Clean rags or towels
  • String or a large rubber band

Breaking in Techniques

There are several methods for breaking in a catcher’s mitt, and it’s essential to choose the one that works best for you. You can also combine techniques to achieve the desired flexibility and fit.

Playing Catch

The most natural way to break in a mitt is simply by playing catch. The repeated impact of the ball will help soften and shape the glove, making it more comfortable and easier to use. Aim for at least 30 minutes of catch per day for several weeks.

Mallet Method

A rubber mallet can be used to simulate the impact of a baseball on your mitt, helping to break it in more quickly. With your hand in the mitt, strike the pocket and other stiff areas repeatedly. 

You can also place a baseball in the pocket and strike it with the mallet. This method can be used in conjunction with playing catch to expedite the break-in process.


Some players prefer to use steam to soften their mitts. This method involves placing the mitt in a glove steamer for a specified amount of time, usually around 10-15 minutes. 

After steaming, the glove will be more pliable, allowing you to shape it more easily. It’s important to note that not all mitts are suitable for steaming, so check the manufacturer’s recommendations before trying this method.

Glove Oils and Conditioners

Glove oils and conditioners can be used to moisturize and soften the leather, making it more flexible. Apply a small amount of oil or conditioner to a clean rag and gently rub it into the mitt, focusing on stiff areas. 

Avoid using too much oil, as it can weaken the leather and cause it to become too heavy. Allow the mitt to dry for at least 24 hours before using it.

How to Play Catcher in Slow Pitch Softball

Shaping Your Mitt

While breaking in your mitt, it’s essential to shape it to your hand. To do this, place a baseball in the pocket, close the glove around it, and secure it with a rubber band or string. 

This will help create the perfect pocket for catching balls. Make sure to do this whenever you’re not using the mitt during the break-in process.

Caring for Your Mitt

Proper care is crucial for maintaining the performance and longevity of your mitt. Follow these tips to keep your mitt in top shape:

  • Clean your mitt regularly with a damp cloth to remove dirt and sweat.
  • Apply a leather conditioner every few months to maintain the leather’s softness and flexibility.
  • Store your mitt in a cool, dry place when not in use to prevent mold and mildew growth.
  • Avoid exposing your mitt to excessive heat or moisture, as this can cause the leather to become brittle and crack.

Mistakes to Avoid

While breaking in your mitt, avoid these common mistakes:

  • Over-oiling the mitt, which can weaken the leather.
  • Using direct heat sources, such as ovens or microwaves, to soften the mitt.
  • Submerging the mitt in water, which can cause the leather to warp and lose its shape.

Patience is Key

Breaking in a catcher’s mitt takes time and patience. It’s essential not to rush the process, as doing so can damage the mitt and compromise its performance. Stick to the methods outlined in this guide, and you’ll be rewarded with a mitt that feels like an extension of your hand.


How long does it take to break in a catcher’s mitt?

The time it takes to break in a mitt varies depending on the method used and the quality of the leather. On average, it can take anywhere from a few weeks to a couple of months to achieve the desired flexibility and fit.

Can I use any oil on my catcher’s mitt?

It’s best to use oils and conditioners specifically designed for baseball gloves, as they are formulated to protect and soften the leather without causing damage. 

Avoid using any products containing petroleum jelly, motor oil, or household oils, as these can harm the leather and reduce its lifespan.

Can I speed up the process of breaking in my catcher’s mitt?

There are several ways to speed up the process of breaking in a catcher’s mitt, such as using a glove mallet to pound the glove’s pocket, applying glove oil or conditioner regularly, and storing a ball in the pocket overnight. 

However, it’s important to avoid using extreme heat sources, like a microwave or oven, as this can damage the leather and weaken the glove’s structure.


Breaking in a catcher’s mitt is an essential part of getting it game-ready. While the process can take some time, it is well worth the effort to achieve a comfortable and effective fit. 

Using proper oils and conditioners, along with some practical techniques, can speed up the process and help prolong the life of the mitt. 

The key is to be patient and persistent with the break-in process, and over time, the mitt will conform to your hand and become a valuable asset in the game of baseball. So, keep working on your mitt, and soon you’ll be ready to catch those fly balls with ease!

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Notify of

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x